Tupelo Data Room

insurance agency for Sale

Similar businesses sell at 1.4x to 5.2x SDE. Compare live listings and connect with sellers.

Insurance Agencies

Add-On: FL Based / Independent P&C Insurance Agency / $2.57M TTM Rev

FL, US

Add-On Opportunity: Florida Based / Independent P&C Insurance Agency / $2.57M TTM Revenue / ~$1.0M Adj. EBITDA / 86% Personal Lines Company Overview With offices in Palm Coast, Minneola, and Lady Lake, Florida, the Company is an independent property and casualty insurance agency offering personal and commercial coverage through a diversified network of carriers and intermediaries. The agency has operated under current ownership since 2018 and was assembled through six acquisitions of agencies and insurance books. The acquired operations now use one brand, one agency-management system, and centralized leadership. The owner and President have passive roles. An experienced Chief Operating Officer manages daily operations across all three offices, supported by office managers, team leads, producers, and service staff. Key KPIs • $2.57 million of TTM revenue • Approximately $1.0 million of TTM adjusted EBITDA • 38.8% TTM adjusted EBITDA margin • $704,000 of TTM reported EBITDA • $1.11 million of FY2025 adjusted EBITDA • $2.36 million of TTM carrier commissions • $215,000 of TTM contingency bonuses • Approximately 86% of revenue from personal lines • Approximately 92% of revenue from carrier commissions • 87 carriers and intermediaries represented during the TTM period • 203 payers generating commissions during the TTM period • 116 commercial clients during the TTM period • 96.7% FY2025 personal-lines net revenue retention measured by carrier • 95.3% FY2025 net retention across all commission payers • Three Florida offices • 18 employees • Six completed agency and book acquisitions • Third-party acquisition notes repaid in 2025 The Company’s personal-lines offerings include homeowners, mobile homes, coastal homes, personal auto, rental dwellings, and flood insurance. Commercial offerings include general liability, property, commercial auto, trucking, workers’ compensation, builder’s risk, directors and officers, umbrella, excess, and surety coverage. The agency earns commissions when policies are written and again at renewal. Carrier commissions represented 91.7% of TTM revenue, while contingency bonuses represented 8.3%. Exceptional Add-On Opportunity The Company would be an exceptional add-on for a national or regional insurance brokerage seeking additional scale in Florida. A strategic buyer would gain: • Approximately $1.0 million of adjusted EBITDA • An established presence across Central and Northeast Florida • Approximately $2.36 million of annual commission revenue • A predominantly renewal-based personal-lines book • Access to a broad carrier and intermediary network • An operating management team that does not depend on the owner • Three offices already using one agency-management system • A demonstrated history of integrating acquired agencies and books • An established infrastructure for further Florida roll-in acquisitions The largest carrier generated 22.9% of TTM commissions, and the top 10 generated 69.7%. An established aggregator could absorb this concentration within a larger carrier portfolio while using its own market access to improve placement options. Financial Trends TTM revenue declined modestly from FY2025, primarily because lower rates from certain carriers reduced personal-lines commission revenue. Adjusted EBITDA remained approximately $1.0 million despite the rate environment and higher payroll and benefits. Excluding contingency bonuses, commissions averaged approximately $196,000 per month during the TTM period. Personal-lines net revenue retention measured by carrier was 96.7% in FY2025. The adjusted EBITDA calculation includes approximately $234,000 of compensation normalization because the owner and President have passive roles and the COO already runs daily operations. It also includes approximately $29,000 of personal expenses and approximately $31,000 of timing, discretionary, and one-time items.

-Asking Price
$2,570,000Revenue
$2,570,000Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Established Insurance franchise

Oakland Park, Broward County, FL, US

Established Insurance franchise opportunity specializing in Auto insurance. Highly visible location in East Fort Lauderdale. This turnkey insurance agency benefits from strong traffic, excellent visibility, and an established presence in the community. The franchise is a recognized brand offering auto, home, commercial, renters, and other insurance products. Franchise offers Progressive & GEICO and many more appts. This is ideal for an owner-operator or insurance professional looking to acquire an existing location rather than starting from scratch. Franchise systems, brand recognition, and an established operating platform provide a strong foundation for continued growth. Excellent opportunity in the desirable South Florida market. Owner operator makes $183k for 2025. One week Franchise training in Miami. Buyer pays transfer/training fee. Buyer must be approved by franchisor. Buyer must have 220 license. Great books &records. 2025/2024 Tax Returns on file.

$750,000Asking Price
$528,333Revenue
$183,170Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Extremely Profitable Franchise Insurance Agency

Miami, Miami-Dade County, FL, US

Extremely Profitable Franchise Insurance Agency. One of South Florida’s Iconic Franchise brands! This location is one of the top 25 producing franchises in the system. This company provides Standard/Non-Standard Insurance for Auto/Home/commercial/Boat & Ticket Defense. They have established appointments with Geico/Progressive/Star Casualty/United Auto/Ocean Harbor/Gainsco/Kemper/Legacy/Ascendant/Citizens/Foremost/Universal Property/AM Wins & more. This high-visibility location sits in a densely populated area with heavy foot and vehicle traffic, providing excellent exposure and walk-in potential. The agency enjoys a loyal client base and strong renewal income. This is a turnkey opportunity with trained staff in place, ongoing franchisor support, and low overhead. Ideal for a hands-on owner-operator with a 220 license is a must. Seller is willing to provide transitional support for 1 month. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a recession-resistant business in a growing community. 2024 Owner Benefit over 500k+with over $1.1 million in net commissions after royalties. $17,500 Transfer fee paid by the buyer. 220 license required!

$1,500,000Asking Price
$1,925,552Revenue
$562,817Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Turnkey Independent Agency | Medicare Focused

Cook County, IL, US

Established in 2015, this independent insurance agency provides comprehensive health and Medicare insurance solutions across the Chicagoland area. Operated solely by the owner-agent, the business has built strong relationships with a broad network of reputable insurance carriers, enabling it to offer tailored coverage options to a diverse client base. The agency’s revenue is primarily driven by Medicare products, supported by additional income streams from life insurance and group insurance policies. It’s focused niche, recurring client needs, and strong carrier access position the business for continued stability and growth. Designed for flexibility, the operation is easily relocatable and well-suited for a home-based setup, offering low overhead and scalability for a new owner. Financial Highlights: • Sellers Discretionary Earnings (SDE): $94,000 • List Price: $350,000 This turnkey opportunity is ideal for a licensed agent seeking an established book of business or an existing agency looking to expand within the high demand senior insurance market

$350,000Asking Price
-Revenue
-Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Broward Insurance Franchise

Pembroke Pines, Broward County, FL, US

Established Franchise Insurance agency located in South Broward. Turnkey opportunity in a dense, high-traffic market. The business provides a full range of products including auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance, supported by strong carrier relationships and a loyal, diverse client base. Bilingual service drives consistent referrals and repeat business. Revenue is generated through commissions and renewals, creating stable, recurring income. The operation is well-positioned for growth through expanded marketing, cross-selling, and additional product lines. Ideal for an owner-operator looking for an established presence with immediate cash flow in the South Florida insurance market. 2025 Commissions $450k. Purchaser pays for transfer fee. Must have a 220 license.

$550,000Asking Price
$451,599Revenue
$130,444Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Franchise Insurance Agency Dade

Miami, Miami-Dade County, FL 33161, US

Established Franchise Auto Insurance agency located in NE Dade. Turnkey opportunity in a dense, high-traffic market. The business provides a full range of products including Std/Non Std auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance, supported by strong carrier relationships and a loyal, diverse client base. Bilingual service drives consistent referrals and repeat business. Revenue is generated through commissions and renewals, creating stable, recurring income. The operation is well-positioned for growth through expanded marketing, cross-selling, and additional product lines. Ideal for an owner-operator looking for an established presence with immediate cash flow in the South Florida insurance market. 350k+ Commissions. Purchaser pays for transfer fee. Must have a current 220 license and be planning to work in the existing franchise. This is not a book that can be transferred to another agency (must stay as a franchise)

$400,000Asking Price
$356,371Revenue
$115,315Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Established Insurance Franchise

West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, FL 33401, US

Reason for Sale:Career Change- Established franchise insurance agency in West Palm Beach. Turnkey opportunity in a growing, high-traffic market. The business provides auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance products supported by strong carrier relationships and a loyal, diverse client base. Bilingual service drives referrals and repeat business. Revenue is generated through commissions and renewals, creating stable, recurring income. The agency is well-positioned for growth through expanded marketing, cross-selling, and additional product offerings. Ideal for an owner-operator seeking an established presence with immediate cash flow in Palm Beach County. 2025 Commissions $574k. Very efficiently run office. Must have a current 220 license.

$1,000,000Asking Price
$574,984Revenue
$252,786Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies

Established, Profitable, Independent Insurance Agency for Sale

Cook County, IL, US

Wildly successful independent insurance agency for sale with minimum 35%+ year over year growth since 2020 focusing on mainly personal auto insurance AND a separate revenue stream (i.e. car registration that makes up 46% of revenue) located next to a DMV. We repeat that almost 50% of the revenue of this business comes from car registration sales. For those looking for only a book of insurance business to transfer without this additional revenue stream being taken into consideration, this business is not for you and will not value out based on typical insurance agency metrics. With excellent reviews, this agency has managed to sell and secure over 1,700 policies and 3,700+ customers with direct appointments (no aggregator) located in a southwest suburb of Cook County. Please also note there is a decent amount of non-standard policies within the book of business that is being sold, i.e. 25% standard / 75% non-standard. Carriers included, but are not limited to: Progressive, Nationwide, Berkshire Hathaway (Guard), Hartford, First Chicago, and Foremost. It comes with an excellent, affordable office space. Word of mouth has been their only source of growth so there is still tremendous room to grow with marketing. 2024 gross revenue was over $700k with $400k in SDE. Speaking Arabic would be an absolute plus, but not necessary based on the clientele and location of the agency. This is an excellent tack on for a buyer that already has an agency and/or it can be rebranded as needed. The seller's preferences would be a buyer that already knows the insurance industry, but it can also serve as a massive head start for someone trying to break into the insurance industry. Inquire within for more information. PREFERRED CASH OR CONVENTIONAL LENDING BUYER FUNDING.

$1,150,000Asking Price
-Revenue
-Cash Flow
Insurance Agencies
+1

Established Allstate Agency – Grossing $900K / Netting $480K

NY, US

Opportunity to acquire a high-performing, turnkey Allstate book of business located in the lucrative New York and Connecticut markets. This agency boasts: ? Gross Commissions: Approx. $900,000/year ? Net Profit: Approx. $480,000/year ? Policy Count: 2,575+ active policies ? Product Mix: 90% P&C | 5% Life | 5% Commercial ? Retention Rate: High client loyalty ? Location: Nassau, NY – Easily accessible and well-established office ? Staff: Experienced 3-person sales/service team, average tenure of 2+ years ? Technology: Fully digitized records, E-Agent management system ? Lease: 5-year lease at $2,900/month with 3% annual increases ? Real Estate: Option to purchase the building where the agency is located ? FFE Included: Furniture, fixtures, and equipment valued at approx. $50,000 This agency offers an exceptional return and solid foundation for continued growth. With strong brand recognition, stable earnings, a seasoned team in place, and real estate optionality, this is a perfect fit for experienced operators or first-time buyers seeking a plug-and-play opportunity in a high-demand region. ? Inquire today to receive the full information package and take the first step toward acquiring this top-performing Allstate agency.

$2,500,000Asking Price
$900,000Revenue
$480,000Cash Flow

Market Snapshot

National transaction benchmarks for insurance agency businesses.

Under $500K

Median revenue$227k
Median cash flow$121k
Median sale price$255k
Multiple range1.4x - 2.6x

$500K to $2M

Median revenue$568k
Median cash flow$219k
Median sale price$975k
Multiple range3.6x - 5.2x

A variety of factors can cause businesses to trade outside this range, including earnings quality, operational transferability, key-person risk, growth trajectory, and geography, so a listing priced above or below the typical multiple usually reflects real differences in the underlying business.

What to know about insurance agency acquisitions

GW

By George Wellmer

Cofounder & CEO

Key diligence, valuation, financing, and transition considerations for buyers evaluating insurance agency acquisitions.

Two different transaction types: full agency vs book of business

A full agency sale transfers the operating company — staff, brand, technology, carrier contracts, lease, and the book of business. It's valued on adjusted EBITDA. A book of business sale transfers only the client list and the future commission stream; the buyer plugs the new clients into their existing operational infrastructure. Book of business sales are valued on revenue multiples — 1.5x-2.5x annual commissions for typical P&C books. These are fundamentally different transactions with different prices, different financing, and different operational implications. Buyers should know which type they're pursuing from day one.

Carrier appointments are the most undervalued asset

An agency's value depends heavily on which carriers it's appointed with. Carrier appointments aren't automatically transferable; the carrier reviews the new owner and can revoke the relationship at acquisition. Some appointments take 12-18 months to acquire from scratch (especially admitted-market specialty carriers). Buyers should confirm which appointments transfer, which require carrier re-approval, and what alternative appointments the buyer might fall back on if a key carrier walks. An agency with 15 active carriers including hard-to-get admitted markets is a different asset than one with 5 carriers, all easily replaceable.

Retention rate is the bellwether metric

P&C client retention above 85% annually is strong; above 90% is exceptional. Below 80% raises serious concerns about service quality, pricing, or client base composition. Retention compounds, a 90% retention book holds together for 10 years while an 80% retention book is half-gone in 4 years. Buyers should request the agency management system data showing retention by policy year and by line of business. Discount the valuation aggressively for retention below market norms.

P&C, life and health, commercial, and personal lines have different economics

Personal lines P&C (auto, home) generates high-volume but lower-per-policy commissions and is increasingly disrupted by direct-to-consumer carriers (Geico, Progressive direct). Commercial lines P&C generates higher per-policy commissions and is less direct-channel-vulnerable. Life insurance commissions are heavily weighted to year-one new business with thinner trail commissions. Health insurance commissions face structural pressure from Medicare Advantage consolidation. Buyers should know exactly what the book's composition is by line and assess whether the line mix is structurally growing, stable, or shrinking.

Producer concentration and relationship risk

Many independent agencies have one or two top producers driving most of the revenue. When a top producer leaves, whether to a competitor, retirement, or with the seller, the book moves with them. Buyers should ask for revenue concentration by producer, retention agreements in place, and any non-compete or non-solicit terms. Where a producer is critical, the deal should include retention bonuses or earn-out structures tied to the producer staying through transition.

Deal structures favor earn-outs over lump sums

Most insurance agency acquisitions are structured with significant earn-out components meaning payments are tied to retention of acquired clients over 2-3 years. A pure lump-sum sale is rare. Typical structures: 50-70% paid at closing, with the remainder paid over 24-36 months contingent on client retention. This protects the buyer from client departure post-closing but means the seller has continuing economic interest in maintaining relationships through the transition. Buyers should understand the earn-out structure carefully. For example a generous headline price with aggressive retention hurdles can end up costing more than a smaller lump-sum offer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to common buyer questions for this market.

A full agency sale transfers the operating company which includes staff, technology, carrier contracts, brand, and clients. A book of business sale transfers only the client list and renewal commissions. The business buyer plugs the clients into their existing infrastructure. Full agency sales are typically valued on EBITDA multiples; book sales on revenue multiples.